LOS ANGELES —"Star Search"judgeSarah Michelle Gellardoes not throw around top scores willy-nilly onNetflix's rebooted talent competition.
While fellow judgesJelly RollandChrissy Teigenstarted tossing out perfect five-star marks judging the live show that premiered Jan. 20, the"Cruel Intentions"star, 48, held out.
"I don't take five stars lightly. I waited to give that five-star," Gellar tells USA TODAY. "I actually felt badly because both other judges had given fives and I hadn't. It was like 'Am I just the mean judge?'"
Gellar didn't set aSimon Cowell-esque streakon "Star Search," which streams live Tuesdays and Wednesdays (9 ET/6 PT) through the Feb. 17 finale.
'Star Search' revival is hereHow to watch, vote. See judges, cast.
The "Buffy the Vampire Slayer" actress bestowed her first five-star rating to the last performer on the Jan. 21 Episode 2 — singer Bear Bailey, whose version of "Hard Fought Hallelujah" brought Jelly Roll (the song's co-writer) to tears.
"When Bear came on stage, I was like, 'That's why I waited!' Because that was a five-star performance," says Gellar. "That performance was the first one that I'd seen this season where I was like, 'Oh, he's ready to win this right now.'"
Bear was eliminated in Episode 4, but Gellar can rely on decades of "Star Search" experience to spot talent. She was a diehard fan of the OG "Star Search," famously hosted by Ed McMahon, during the syndicated show's run from 1983 to 1995 that featured young up-and-coming stars like Beyoncé, Britney Spears and Justin Timberlake.
"Britney Spears, I always remember for some reason. I could always pinpoint her look, the song. But there were so many, like the comedians that I wasn't supposed to watch," says Gellar, who didn't even know her good friend and"All My Children"co-star Lindsay Price also appeared on "Star Search" until researching the show.
"And I was watching the acting category the other day, and there was a contestant namedMitzi Kapture,who was later on 'Silk Stockings,'" says Gellar. "There are people that you don't even realize were on the show."
How Sarah Michelle Gellar was nearly on the original 'Star Search'
Not Gellar, however. The child actress who starred in 1980s Burger King commercials auditioned unsuccessfully for the TV talent show.
"In the original 'Star Search,' there was an acting category where they'd have two performers start the scene, and then two performers end the scene," says Gellar. "I think I was five. But I'd been working for a while by then. And alas, I didn't make it."
Scroll through for more photos of her life and career. " style="max-width:100%; height:auto; border-radius:6px; margin:10px 0;" loading="lazy" />
Sydney Sweeney photos: Look back at the 'Euphoria' star's best looks, career
The Emmy-nominated star of"Euphoria"and"The White Lotus," Sydney Sweeney, has made a name for herself in prestige television, on silver screens in horror flicks or romantic comedies and as a fashion darling on red carpets like theMet Gala.Scroll through for more photos of her life and career.
The Hollywood vet, who landed her first big role as a teen soap star on "All My Children," eventually found stardom, and even other performers who also had star careers after not making the "Star Search" cut.
"I'm not alone in my club. I've found out that John Legend also did not make it on," says Gellar of Teigen's EGOT-winning husband. "So we have a support group now, and we help each other through the difficult times. But it shows that you can't give up on your dreams. It might take a while, but I wound up on 'Star Search.'"
"The Voice" coach Legend also gave some helpful advice to the judging newbie.
"He said to find your own voice. It has to be authentic," says Gellar, who says the show is unique. "We're looking for a star, not the most talented singer or model or dancer. It's just this combination of things that makes magic."
Gellar has the opportunity to bring out the enchanting sparkle in her outfits and daring heeled boots, despite the potential peril of tripping during live shows.
"It's just fun and silly excuse to wear the things you would never normally wear," says Gellar. "I'm scared every show that I'm going to be the one who falls."
During the live viewing, viewers worldwide can vote for their favorite performers in the global Netflix showcase, a reach that was never possible on the original.
"The viewers are the fourth judge," says Gellar. "I talk to Jelly and Chrissy about this all the time. I was in this industry for a long time before I performed for a worldwide audience. Every contestant on this show has that opportunity. That's huge."
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY:Netflix 'Star Search' puts lethal heels on judge Sarah Michelle Geller