I’m 40 and I’m starting to panic that I’ve missed the boat when it comes to finding a husband – because antiquated as it may sound, I do really want one. I‘ve never been married and I’ve always dreamed of sharing my life with someone special. I’ve had so many three-to-six monthrelationshipsI don’t even know if I could list them all without forgetting someone’s name, but I haven’t met anyone I actually wanted to go the distance with (well, apart from one, who I dated for a year, but he ended up breaking my heart).
I don’t have much of a problem being asked out on dates, thankfully – and I have met a lot of guys who wanted to be with me ... but the ones who have been keen to be “long-term” have always been“nice guys” (or “too nice”,to put it a different way). And even though they were lovely and kind and actually messaged back (rather than disappearing for days on end), I got bored. There wasn’t enough of a “spark” because they had no “edge”.
The men I’m drawn to are charismatic, unpredictable and sweep me off my feet – but they’re all the same: flakey and (ultimately) disrespectful, because they’re not really interested in a “real” relationship. I can tell they probably have two or three women on the go and I end up feeling paranoid and insecure and anxious, the whole time I am with them. But, you can’t help who you’re attracted to, can you? And I seem to beconstantly attracted to “bad boys”.Why can’t I find a “bad boy” who is decent enough to want to settle down? Someone like that must exist?!
Dear Frustrated,
I’m going to ask you a direct and potentially tricky question:what does “too nice” mean to you? At the moment, your definition seems to include men who are (as you have listed): kind and responsive; who want to be in a functional, healthy relationship with you – with commitment and the possibility of a future together – and who aren’t afraid to express that. It’s hard, reading that list, to work out what is so wrong with them – they seem to have all the qualities you would expect someone who is looking for a husband (or a serious relationship) would want. And you claim that that’s you. That thatiswhat you want.
But do you? If you do, why do you think you allow yourself to be swept off your feet, time and time again, by the menyou brand as “bad boys”?With their scattered attention spans, their temporary and fleeting focus? No “bad boy” has ever brought you happiness, according to what you say here. So isn’t it time to break the pattern? To see them, to smile and swoon and sigh a bit – then to ultimately wave them on to torment someone else?
Because you’re right: bad boys are sexy and attractive and charismatic and alluring – and they’re also flakey andbreadcrumbingand (often) terrible at commitment.
Advertisement
Meanwhile, nice guys have historically got a bad rap; they “finish last”, after all. And it feels deeply unfair. As my colleague Alexandra wroteherein October, a study run by researchers looked at how personality traits correlate with relationship status across nearly 4,000 people in Australia, Denmark and Sweden and found that the men who scored highest on agreeableness (how nice they were) were statistically theleast likely to have a partner. The study also found that extroversion counted as a significant advantage for men –outgoing, confident maleswere much more likely to be in relationships (but I wonder if any one of them stretches beyond that three-to-six month limit you describe...).
I wonder if you’re getting so fixated on the idea of someone being “nice” or “bad”; “edgy” or “boring”, that you’re forgetting there’s a whole glorious, strange and interestingly diverse range of people in between. Saying someone is “boring”might just mean they are “shy”(especially on a first date, because you don’t know them yet). I personally don’t believe anyone is boring – it’s on us to be interested enough to find out what is interesting about them.
Which all leads me to ask another question: which personality traits or values are most important to you – and what are you really looking for? Can you define what being “edgy” really means?
If your goal is to feel “excited”, for example, then you are probably suited to someone who has some kind of adventurous hobby – that could be rock climbing, or downhill skiing, or dirt bike racing. Alex Honnold might not be branded a “bad boy”, but he does love adrenaline(just check out the footage of him climbing the Taipei 101 skyscraper without ropes).
If your desire to feel instant “chemistry” or a “spark” is very important to you (and we mustn’t forget that the elusive physical “spark” can often be confused with adrenaline-fuelled fear, or danger, and can sometimes be your body warning you off someone to begin with), then you should probably be sussing out the participantsin a local dance class,like salsa or ballroom. One easy way to tell whether you feel physically drawn to someone is to get up close and physical with them – you can do this in a non-sexual way by dancing with them. It’s worth a try.Pheromonesare powerful beasts.
There are a myriad ways to find what you’re looking for, but I’m going to share with you my greatest tip of all: to change your own mindset (and with it, your expectations). If you really want tofind a steady and committed relationship, then you need to work out what is frightening you (or boring you) when it comes to the people who are prepared to offer exactly that.
What does “too nice” mean – and is it really a negative? Isn’t it entirely possible that saying someone is “too nice” is another way of protecting yourself from embarking on something real; something in which you have the possibility of getting hurt and the expectation of being vulnerable? And isn’t being drawn to a “bad boy” – who you know,instinctively, won’t settle down– just another way of protecting yourself from doing the very same thing?
We’re talking a lot about “bad boys”, but sometimesweare the oneswith the commitment problem. We just need to be honest and admit it.
Do you have a problem you would like to raise anonymously with Dear Vix? Issues with love, relationships, family and work? Email dearvix@independent.co.uk